15 Comments
User's avatar
Chad Montgomery's avatar

"Poetry is not political."

Agreed. It is basic common sense what Nedim's poetry said.

I could not have written it.

Humans are not by nature, democratic.

Aristotle = Hierarchies + pro slavery

Confucianism = Filial Piety

Marxism = hierarchy & subordination

Democracy, at least in 2025, requires Human Rights. If China or Russia want to give you easy money, that is a more easier, solvent solution than the messy guck of democracy and loving strangers. America, through all of its sins, does a hell of a job at unity. Is it from the Declaration or Constitution? No one reads those documents. Is it from the bulwark of Abraham Lincoln?

What churns the Idea of America? Coming into form after 9/11 makes this hard. Millennials and Gen Z almost live in an entirely different version of America than their predecessors. Trying to reverse your mind back in history hits the 1980s and then stops. Back then is not real anymore and requires serious scholarship.

It seems like what unified America was successful wars plus a resource rich land. Even if say, Reconstruction was something I am an expert on, our culture + politicians I have never heard any meaningful discussion of history so we are all idiots now??? I know history, I have just not conversed it with too many people and mainstream institutions are deprived of it.

So what churns the Idea of America is nothing glamorous, rather, more land + more capital & resources throw in a Constitution and Declaration that very few people actually read and we make it by. My generation and younger still have not form a historical-political identity.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

This poetry is expression of injustice.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

How could someone like Erdogan not care or feel or acknowledge poetry and injustice like Nedim???

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

Why do "idiots" like me "think their sold" on Nedim 100% until they "hear is poetry" and then revved up another 10%!!!???

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

Nedim has "Jeremi Suri energy."

What do India and Turkey have in common? Good food.

I am not happy with the Romans' loss in 1453, but... India I actually know little about their history...

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

I am appalled Turkey has turned into this latrine of a country.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

The episode proves everyone is a part of history.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

All life matters. We are all wired and connected together. Life should be led and struggled to the last breath.

A "war" metaphor of life works... But I prefer a "democracy" metaphor.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

In a "democracy" metaphor, there still exists war, but

the essence of democracy is not "helping each other"

but the essence of democracy is liberty which, need be defended, but more importantly, enjoyed.

The "war" metaphor of life makes 100% sense but they don't know how to party or eliminate interstitial violence -- or the gaps between control and violence. That is why I am such a big feminist and female advocate.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

This is so inspiring to a loner like me who aspires to be a military historian and write about peace, war, democracy.

Nedim Turfent, I don't think I am going to forget this episode. Sometimes I feel like I am talking or writing to myself. I have had bad days, but, ya ya "my life could always be worse."

--But Nedim Turfent is making me feel like neurogenesis is going on.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

This sound odd. I hope I am being polite.

But, I kind of needed Nedim Turfent!!!

This is one hell of a brain-energy supplemental boost!!! Haha!!!

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

I'm ready to go into battle! Take on Hector! Take on Achilles!!!

Aristeia!!!

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

This is so powerful.

I do not know why but my brain is bringing up Francis Scott Key and the Magna Carta.

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

"Moral Conscious of world"

"Freedom of speech"

Freedom of press"

Expand full comment
Chad Montgomery's avatar

Nedim has more pelts than Dr. Suri!

Expand full comment